Yellowstone Fishes: Ecology, History, and Angling in the Park


Introduction

  • Yellowstone is being preserved in its natural state, as much for the fish as for the bears

  • Trout are too valuable to be caught only once

  • “If fish could scream a lot of things would be different

  • Yellowstone’s fame as a scientific treasure has been exceeded by its fame as a sportfishing mecca



Part 1

“The World of Yellowstone Fishes”


Chapter 1

The Yellowstone Setting 

  • Objective:

    • “Preservation of the natural ecosystem for the educational, scientific, and cultural benefit of the citizens of the US and the world”

  • Geologic Creation

    • 75 mya crustal uplift

    • 50 mya Rockies form

    • 2.1 Mya largest Yellowstone eruption

    • 631,000 ybp latest eruption

      • 1,000 square miles

      • Hayden Valley and Old Faithful epicenter

    • 14,000 ybp last ice age

    • 9,500-7,000 ybp wetter climate

    • 1,600 ybp modern climate

  • Land and water have only been ice-free for a short time

    • Relatively few types of life

    • Poor, thin, infertile soil

    • Many waterfalls (barriers)

      • >200 large waterfalls

  • Springs introduce heat and minerals

    • Startling contrast in productivity

    • 747 worth of minerals wash out the Madison every day

  • Water, like land, is part of the wilderness

  • Fishless that 1% stream biomass

  • Aquatic ecosystems of the park originate as rain and snowfall

    • Mostly absorbed into the ground

    • Replenishes aquifer

    • Ensures steady spring activity

  • Water leeches substances from decaying vegetation

    • Gives water the color of tea

  • Young fish eat some plants but mostly fungi, bacteria, and plankton

  • Insect “groups”

    • Shredders

      • Salmon flies

    • Collectors

      • Filter feeders

      • Gather bottom material

    • Scrapers 

      • Mayfly nymphs

      • Scrape algae off rocks

    • Piercers

      • Caddisfly larvae

  • The richer the insect diversity the richer the fish diversity

  • Large dragonfly nymphs occasionally prey on young trout

  • Typically it’s a straight jump up the food chain from insect to fish

  • Trout consume 5% of body weight in insects each summer day

  • YNP supports 40lbs of fish per acre

    • 113,000 water acres



Chapter 2

Three Rivers Named Yellowstone


  • The last great undammed river in the lower 48

    • Long tale of bitter political struggle

  • Gathered drainage of 60% percent of the park

  • Hidatsa Sioux named it  for cliffs outside Billings, MT

    • Crow called it Elk River

  • River neither begins nor ends in the park

  • 1st section, Bridger-Teton wilderness

    • Poor food

    • Smallest fish population

    • Contains many fish only after spring floods subside

    • Fish migrate up from the lake

    • 12 kya

      • Fish colonized over Two Ocean Pass

      • Trout and Dace

  • 2nd section, Yellowstone Lake

    • Infertile stream to organically rich river

    • Lake has a moderating influence 

      • Less flooding

      • Less erosion

    • Acts as a settling basin allowing more light

    • Higher rate of photosynthesis

    • Warming basin

      • Optimum trout temperatures all year round

    • Much larger than 1st river

    • The most famous section, most wildlife

    • Severely overfished section of the river

    • Historic fish weigh 2.5lbs - 4.5lbs

      • Currently 1 lb - 1.5 lbs

    • Portions closed for wildlife access

      • Viewing

      • Sanctuary

  • 3rd River

    • Longest section (36 miles)

    • Grand Canyon to Northern Boundary

      • Canyon carved over the last 200,000 years

      • 20 miles inside the canyon

    • Lamar River is the largest tributary in the park

    • Sportfish introduced in MT affect fish

    • Above Knowles Falls (north of Gardinier) cutthroats are still the primary fish

    • Chance to catch 5 species of sportfish

      • 4 trout and whitefish

    • Not parallel by any road!




Chapter 3

Yellowstone Lake


  • “The wonders of this place shouldn’t be concealed in mere statistics”

  • “I doubt that even in a lifetime anyone could ever catch all of its moods”

  • “A vast unbroken expanse of ice, wind, and silence” 

  • 60th largest lake in the world

    • 2nd largest alpine lake (over 7,000 ft)

  • Was much larger in the past 

    • 2x as large

    • 300ft higher shoreline

  • Avg. 140 ft deep

    • 428 max depth

    • Most cutthroat <90 feet of water

  • 12 million acre-feet of water

    • 1.1 million acre-feet of outflow

    • Lake Mead ~26 million acre-feet of water

  • Mary Bay

    • Bottomless Pit 60-180 ft

    • Pipe gardens at the bottom

    • Disappeared after earthquake

  • Generally low productivity

    • Insoluble rhyolite

    • Low nutrients 

    • Limited productivity

  • Trout diet in lakes

    • Algae, bacteria, plankton, pine pollen

    • Diaptomus Shoshone

      • Red pigment passed to fish

  • 18 species of plants

    • Star duckweed

    • Richards pondweed

    • Grow from 3-30 feet or 20-55 feet in windswept areas

  • Invertebrates

    • Shrimp, flies, mayflies, caddisflies, fingernail clams, aquatic worms

    • No large invertebrates

  • Large trout follow the shoreline May-July

    • Search for food

  • Birds eat ~ 200,000 lbs of trout per year

    • Fisherman 20k-30k per year

    • Little competition between birds

      • Osprey: Immature fish

      • Pelicans: Mature fish

      • Grizzly: Spawning fish

      • Dippers: Fry and eggs

      • Kingfishers: Fingerlings

  • Closer to pristine conditions than any large lake in the Lower 48

    • 1900-1955 removed 800 million eggs to translocate

      • 48 million fish commercially harvested

    • 1960 population collapse

  • 1975 policy 13-inch max size catch

    • Largest fish: more eggs, bigger fry, and migrate farther upstream

  • Minnow fishermen introduced suckers, shiners, and chub into the lake

  • 1985 Brook trout introduced into lake tributary

    • Killed off with rotenone


Environmental Vandalism

  • Late 1980’s 

    • Reports of occasional lake trout

      • Informal and ignored

  • July 30, 1994

    • The guide brought 19-inch lake trout to rangers

    • Illegal and stupid

  • The suspected founder fish had been in the lake since the 1980s

  • Optimizing Lake Trout Targeting

    • Net size

    • Net location

    • Spawning locations

      • Judas fish

  • Larger lake trout (14+ inches) eat around 90 cutthroats per year

  • When lake trout are introduced into non-native lakes they wipe out other fish

  • By 1980 Yellowstone's cutthroat range reduced by 90%

  • Prediction of sport fishing decline from 36 million to 8.5 million


Not Just a Fish Story

  • 42 Species of birds and mammals are tied to the Yellowstone cutthroat

  • Nutrient cycling in plants and riparian uptake “beyond complex ways”

  • Osprey eat only cutthroats

    • Eagles also eat many ducks 

  • Grizzly bears most prolific fisherman

    • Dumps closed and more bears turned to fishing

    • Sows with 2 cubs 100 fish per day for 10 days during spawn

  • DDT

    • Fish population down

    • Fewer fishing bears

  • Lake trout cannot replace cutthroat, not bioavailable


Not Just a Lake Story

  • Effects not limited to the lake fish

  • Fish migrate to the lake in fall and become vulnerable

    • Migrate in the fall to avoid freezing streams


The Hope

  • Lake trout can also be overharvested

  • The cutthroat population only slightly reduced

  • Cost 300,000 per year (1995)

  • Right net types, times, places, and depths

  • Less expensive than fishery collapse

  • Long-term commitment




Chapter 4

The Madison River System


  • YNP preserved for assortment of unusual geologic and geothermal wonders

  • Life begins at 2 sources

    • Natural precipitation

    • Geothermal near rivers

  • Obvious differences

    • Temperature

    • Sodium bicarbonate

    • Iron, sulfur, arsenic, mercury, fluoride, lead

  • Firehole (unacceptable to drink)

    • 25% of the flow from hot springs

    • 47- 87 degrees ((winter-summer)

      • Optimum trout growth temperatures

    • Sometimes called a chalk stream

      • Not a true chalk-stream

  • Gibbon gets 20% of water from hot springs

  • “Iconic” trout streams but relatively lifeless

  • Rainwater is 5.5pH

    • No fish outside of 4.3pH - 10pH

  • Gibbon mildly acidic

    • More diversity

  • Firehole mildly alkaline

    • More organisms

  • Fish live up to 90 degrees

  • Much of Madison was without fish

    • Above Firehole falls

    • Above Gibbon falls

    • Madison had west-slope cutthroats, grayling, and whitefish

    • Since stocked with brooks, browns, and rainbows

  • Fish survival strategy

    • Rainbows highly adaptable

      • Retreat when the water hits 80

    • Browns avoid all warmer waters

  • Some fish in the warmest waters never mature sexually

    • Some have switched spawning times

  • Rainbows in Firehole grow faster than hatchery fish

    • 1 foot long in 1 year

    • Normally 1 foot long in 4 years



Chapter 5

Wild Water - Rare to Well Done


  • The small streams above Turbid Lake contain trout that have been isolated from Yellowstone Lake for 1000s of years

  • 2 Lakes in the park with otter populations that feed on salamanders, not fish

  • The most important factors governing the life types found in a body of water are:

    • Heat

    • Water Chemistry

    • Volume

    • Sunlight

  • Water chemistry is the most complex!

    • It’s a function of the land it flows over

    • Also affected by hot springs

  • 3 Stream types

    • Dilute

      • Few chemicals, distilled water

      • Most organics from decaying plants

      • Tea colored water

    • Sodium bicarbonate

      • Minerals from rhyolite

      • Yellowstone, Lewis, and Shoshone Lakes

    • Calcium bicarbonate

      • Common in northern Yellowstone

  • 2 Less common types

    • Calcium sulfate

    • Sodium sulfate

    • Very acidic

    • Influenced by geothermal activity

  • Sodium chloride (rarest)

    • Strong geothermal

  • 3 categories of productivity

    • Oligotrophic: Low production, low organics, low inorganics, high oxygen

      • Blue water

    • Dystrophic: Low production, high organics, low inorganics, low oxygen

      • Tea colored water

    • Eutrophic: High production, high organics, high inorganics, high oxygen


Acid, Pollution, and Wilderness

  • Extremely productive waters dominated by just a few organisms

  • Low productivity usually diverse 

  • Nymph Lake

    • Fed by Frying Pan Springs (pH1)

    • Silica-rich waters allow easy production of diatom shells

    • Highest diatom diversity in the park

  • Detergent foam - “Indian soap”

    • Organic molecules leached from decaying plant matter

  • Fluoride has to be removed from Madison to make it drinkable

  • Mercury and arsenic in Firehole

    • Trout unfit for consumption

  • Radioactive isotopes along the pitchstone plateau

  • Human pollution 

    • Petroleum products

    • Mine tailings

  • “Is it pollution if Mother Nature is the perpetrator?


Fewer Lakes and Ponds Without Fish

  • Many lakes were never colonized by fish

  • 8,200 ft max elevation for salamanders

  • Phantom midge larvae largest predator in many high-elevation lakes

  • Leeches present in all park waters

  • Non-fish life is a good indicator of whether fish are present

  • Introduced fish demolish insects

  • Fishless waters promote wilderness

    • Fewer granola bar wrappers on the banks



Chapter 6

Fires and Fish


  • 1950s and 1960s forest service experimented with letting fires burn

  • 1972 set aside backcountry zones to allow fires

  • Streams are nutrient exporters

  • 1988 fires gave the entire regional ecological system a jolt

    • A new round of debates and discussions

    • Surge in fire-related research

  • Fish effects

    • The landing rate remained the same

    • Average size increased

    • More fishermen and more fish than in the 1970s

  • Spring runoff was black


What did Fish do?

  • Some fish boiled 

    • Hard on some aquatic organisms

    • Usually fish and invertebrates survived

  • Firefighting 

    • 1.4 million gallons of retardant

      • No major die-offs were reported

  • Many influences on fire

    • Extent, intensity, vegetation type, elevation, slope, precipitation

  • Increased pace of nutrient cycling

  • Removes shade/ canopy

    • Good for alpine streams

    • Bad for lowland streams

  • Lake effects more subtle

  • Fire isn’t simply a “good” thing

  • Altered groundwater chemistry (not too much)

    • Raised

      • Nitrates, sodium, pH, and potassium

    • Lowered

      • Sulfates, chlorine, calcium

  • 1988 fires had no effect on Lake Yellowstone water chemistry

  • Jackson Lake had noticeably increased sediment load

  • Streams in burned watersheds less able to retain logs and sticks

    • These are used by aquatic invertebrates

  • Trouts suffocated in heavy sediment runoff

  • Changes in insect abundance

    • Decreased carnivores

    • Increased herbivores and insects

  • Over-harvest is way more dangerous than fire


Why the Fires Show How Yellowstone Fishing is Different

  • Rewrote books on fire management

    • Wildland firefighting

    • Management of federal lands

  • Old rule: “Scenery is Greenery”

  • Truly wild lands, in order to remain wild, does things to itself that seem shocking

    • It disassembles and reassembles itself on a scale of centuries with no regard for the brief scale of a human lifespan

  • “Pretty is what works”

  • “We don't want our trout too wild”

  • YNP manages for ecological function rather than bolsters the population of any species

  • Overhaul of YNP regulations in the 1960s and 1970s

    • No kill

    • Managed for a healthy wilderness




Chapter 7

On Being a Fish


  • Fusiform shape

  • Tighten muscles on one side, relax on the other, repeat

  • Fine uses

    • Stabilization

    • Stopping 

    • Turning

    • Hydrofoils

  • Senses

    • Nearsighted

    • Smell receptors on the skin

    • Internal ears

      • Hearing and balance

    • Lateral line

      • Vibration detection, touch from a distance

  • Skin

    • Slime glands promote immunity

    • Can change color!

  • Gills 

    • Oxygen transfer

  • Swim bladder

    • Buoyancy control




Chapter 8

Species Descriptions


18 Species

Native Species

  • 12 species 

  • Low due to recent glaciation


Cutthroat Trout

Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout

  • Clarks Crooked Snout Trout

  • Description

    • Basibranchial teeth (Tongue teeth)

    • Red slash on the throat and gill plates

    • Color varies by age and stream

    • 16 inches

Snake River Fine-Spotted Cutthroat 

  • Description

    • 100s of fine spots on the body

    • Similar to Yellowstone cutthroat trout

    • 16 inches

Westslope Cutthroat Trout

  • Description

    • Similar to above

    • Silvery blue color not yellows

    • Parr Marks (Large spots)

    • Often mistaken for rainbows


  • Distribution

    • Widest range of any subspecies

    • Down to 10% of historic range

      • Inside of Yellowstone National Park is their stronghold

      • West slopes restricted to Cougar Creek

  • Habitat

    • Clear, cold, rocky bottom streams

    • Lakes 20+ feet deep

  • Spawning and Growth

    • Spring stream spawners

    • Move up and downstream from lakes to spawn

    • Males arrive first and fight for prime spots

    • Females arrive second and fight for spots also

    • Redds dug between 4 and 10 inches deep

      • Eggs buried after fertilization

    • 4-5 spawns per year

    • 1000 eggs per spawn

    • 25 days to hatch at 52 degrees

  • 3 Migratory Patterns

    • Downstream to larger streams

    • Upstream to lakes

    • Local dispersal

    • Migrate at night

  • Mature at 12 inches long

    • Males 3-4 years

    • Females 4-5 years

  • Live to be 10-11 years old

  • Food

    • Opportunists

    • Fish, eggs, frogs, mice, insects, snails, crustaceans, plankton, and algae

  • Parks foremost sportfish

  • Easiest trout to catch

    • 2x easier than brook

    • 18x easier than brown

    • Thus they require more protection

  • Highly social fish

    • Capable of living in great densities


Montana Grayling

6 years

15.5 inches

  • Description

    • Trout-like

    • Sail-like dorsal fin

    • Iridescent body

    • Ornate pelvic fins

  • Distribution

    • Circumpolar

    • Confined to 8% of the former range

    • No viable populations in the park

  • Grayling of Grebe Lake 

    • 1931-1956 egg collecting station

    • 72 million eggs sent to 14 states

    • Used to stock the Madison River

  • Habitat

    • Shares rivers with trout and whitefish

    • Use shallower water than trout

  • Spawning and Growth

    • June Spawning 42-48 degree water

    • Inlets and outlets of lakes

    • 2,500-3,500 eggs

    • 17 days to hatch

    • Mature at 2 years

    • 7-12 year lifespan

  • The most beautiful fish in GYE

    • Also tasty


Mountain Whitefish

9 years

17.5 inches

  • Description

    • Large, loose, knobby scales

    • No teeth

    • Grey, no spots

  • Distribution

    • Lower Yellowstone, Madison, and Snake Rivers

  • Habitat

    • Choosier than most fish

    • Deep waters only

    • Large rivers

    • Very sensitive to pollution

      • “Canary Fish”

  • Spawning and Growth

    • Only native fall spawner

      • 50-degree water

      • September - November

    • Mature at 2 years

    • 10 inches 1,400 eggs

    • 20 inches 24,000 eggs

    • No redd or nest

    • Hatch in 38 days

  • 9 years 1.5 lbs

    • 15 years 3 lbs (Rare)

  • Food

    • Bottom feeders

    • Plankton, algae, larvae

    • Nocturnal feeders

    • Compete with chub not trout

  • The ugly duckling of sportfishing


Mountain Sucker

  • Description

    • <8 inches

    • Dark/ Steel gray

  • Distribution

    • Cold clear water

    • <3 feet deep

    • Northwestern US

  • Life History

    • <9 year lifespan

    • Males mature at 3 Females at 4 or 5

    • Eat nearly anything

  • Comment

    • Public distaste

    • “Great at making fish”


Long-nose Sucker

  • Description

    • Gray-olive checkered look

  • Distribution

    • Adaptable

    • Introduced into Lake Yellowstone

  • Life History

    • Prefer deep, quiet waters

    • Massive schools

    • Spawn late spring - early summer

    • Live to 25 years old

    • 20 inches and 3 pounds

    • Mature at 5-7 years

    • Hatch quickly, 14 days

    • High fecundity (35,000 eggs per spawn)

    • Very vulnerable young

    • Eat large quantities of zooplankton

  • Comments

    • Little studied

    • Trout love to feed on suckers


Utah Suckers

  • Description

    • Red-orange lateral line

  • Distribution

    • Varied habitat

    • Depths to 100 feet

  • Life History

    • long-lived, slow-growth

    • 24 years 4 pounds

    • May- June spawners

    • Female matched with 2 males


Mottled Sculpin

  • Description

    • Resembles tiny catfish

  • Distribution 

    • Columbia River to Virginia

    • Only fish native above Gibbon Falls

      • They freaking climbed there!

  • Spawning and growth

    • May and June spawn

    • 700 eggs 

    • Hatch in 30 days

    • Parents guard the nest

    • Mature in 2-3 years

  • Food

    • Small insects

  • Habitat

    • Fast waters

    • Under stones and logs

    • <5 feet deep

    • <70 degrees

    • Seldom seen

  • Comments

    • Darting behavior

    • Imitated on fly

    • 1 sculpin per square foot in Cougar Creek


Redside Shiner

5 years

5 inches

  • Description

    • Small, deeply compressed body

  • Distribution

    • Native to Snake River

    • Introduced everywhere else

  • Habitat

    • <10 Feet deep

    • 50-70 degree water

    • Lakes, Rivers, and Streams

  • Spawning

    • Early July

    • 1,800 eggs

    • Hatch in 21 days

  • Comments

    • Eat plankton

    • Compete with trout

    • Accidental fishermen release into non-native bodies of water


Utah Chub

9 years

12.5 inches

  • Description

    • “Chubby”

    • Highly variable color

  • Distribution

    • Native to ancient Lake Bonneville

  • Spawning and Growth

    • July spawn

    • <4 feet of water

    • 12-inch female, 90,000 eggs

    • Hatch in 2 weeks

    • Slow growth = vulnerable to trout

    • Seek heavy vegetation for protection

    • School for safety

  • Comments

    • Undesirable fish

    • Rivers are rich with trout but lousy with chub

    • Great trout food

      • Trout select prey 25%-30% of their size



Longnose Dace

5 years

4 inches

  • Description

    • Round body

    • Variable color

  • Distribution

    • Temperate North America

  • Habitat

    • Everywhere

    • Back eddies, behind rocks

  • Spawning

    • Early summer

    • 5-inch female 3,400 eggs

  • Food

    • Opportunistic omnivore


Speckled Dace

5 years

3.5 inches

  • Description

    • Similar to other dace

  • Distribution

    • West of the continental divide

  • Habitat

    • Shallow water <5 feet

    • Adaptable

    • Huckleberry Hot Spring at 90 degrees

      • Live below the 150-degree water of the surface

  • Life history

    • Swarms of males prepare a site

    • 3-inch female 500 eggs

    • Hatch in 12 days

    • Bottom feeders


Non-Native Species


Brown Trout

7years

22 inches

  • Distribution

    • Native to Europe

    • Brought to Yellowstone in 1890

  • Habitat

    • Reputation for hardiness and adaptability

    • Less adaptable to temperature

  • Spawning and growth

    • Fall spawners

    • Migrate into small tributaries

    • Build and defend nests

    • Males fight over females

      • Developed hooked jaw “Kype”

    • Incubate over winter

      • 120 day

      • Hatch February through April

    • Grow faster in alkaline waters

  • Food

    • Primarily insects 

    • Targets larger animals also

    • Feed when light is dimmest

  • Comments

    • Most difficult trout to catch

    • Sustain fishing pressure well

    • Highly territorial


Rainbow Trout

7 years

22 inches

  • Description

    • Stouter than cutthroat

    • Bright pink lateral band

    • Spots but no pattern

  • Distribution 

    • Native to us pacific coastal rivers

    • Rare in a pure form inside of YNP

  • Habitat

    • Most adaptable fish

    • Found in most waters in GYE

  • Age and spawning

    • April - July spawning

    • Spawn in colder weather

    • 18-100 days to hatch (38-60 degrees)

  • Food

    • Mid and top-water feeders

    • Mostly insect diet

  • Comments

    • Biggest fighter of all trout

    • Native to the Columbia River 

      • Closest geographic non-native


Eastern Brook Trout

5 years

11 inches

  • Description

    • Tubular look

    • 5:1 ratio

    • Large head

  • Distribution

    • Native to the East Coast

    • Jersey to Georgia

    • Introduced nearly worldwide

  • Habitat

    • Smaller streams and lakes

    • Colder waters (best at 38 degrees)

    • Do well in acidic waters

    • Over-populate areas creating lots of small fish in areas

  • Spawning and growth

    • Fall spawners (September-December)

    • Strongly seek out their hatch site

    • Construct Redds

    • Average 400 eggs per spawn

  • Food

    • Most generalist of trout 

    • Love snails!

  • Comments

    • Gullible fish

    • Out compete cutthroat in many areas

    • Beautiful fish


Lake Trout

20 years

32 inches

  • Distribution

    • Native to Canada and the northern United States

    • Invasive

    • Introduced to Lewis and Heart Lakes in 1890

  • Habitat

    • Cold deep lakes

    • >100 feet

    • Only in shallows at night

  • Spawning and growth

    • September and October spawning (before ice)

    • Spawn in 10-100 feet of water

    • No nests or Redds

    • 113 days to hatch

    • Fry hide in the deepest water

    • The lowest egg-to-size ratio

    • Spawn every other or every third year

  • Food

    • Eat lots of other fish 

    • 90 cutthroats per year

  • Comments

    • Lewis and Shoshone lakes were previously fishless

    • Caught on deep trolls

    • Previously commercial fishery

    • Reintroduced in Great Lakes from Lewis Lake

    • One of the longest-lived animals in Yellowstone 

    • Managers aim to keep fish small to limit cutthroat predation


Lake Chub

4 years

5.5 inches

  • Description

    • Chubby

    • Deeply forked tail

    • Tubercles on scales

  • Distribution 

    • Native to lower Yellowstone and lower snake rivers

    • Introduced by careless bait fishermen

  • Live History

    • Early summer spawn

    • 10 days to hatch



Yellowstone Fishes in The Human Mind


Chapter 9

Wilderness Defined: The Evolution of an Idea


  • Used by natives for 12,000 years

    • Strong archeological evidence

    • A special or sacred place

    • Crossroads for several tribes

    • Shoshone were full residents in the 1800s

  • Creation of YNP complex

    • A few enthusiastic individuals

    • Motivated by personal glory, tourism, and scientific progress

    • “For the benefits and enjoyment of the people”

      • What does that mean?

    • YNP is an experiment in progress 

      • At first, hardly any restrictions were in place

  • Attempts were made to reduce the park size by early railroads

  • Broadening of the park goals

    • Little or no funding for 14 years

    • Lack of enforcement of any rules

  • Inspired by Adirondack Park

    • A major water source for NYC

    • Unharvested forest

  • The idea of GYE was around 100 years before the term was coined

  • 1886 represented a turning point

    • Calvary assigned to the park

  • Visitation up over time

    • First 10 years <10,000 visitors total

    • 20,000 per year in 1910

    • Exceptions made to commercial fishing until 1917

      • After which hotel chefs offered to cook guest-caught fish

  • Fish introduced into many park waters

    • 40% of waters were previously fishless

    • P. Norris wanted carp (thank god that didn’t happen)

    • 57-year hatchery history

  • Notable blunders

    • Introduced Atlantic salmon, yellow perch, and black bass

  • 1919 First creel limits

    • 20 fish per day

    • Depredation of pelicans and gulls

      • 500 pelicans and young killed per year

      • Eggs stomped before hatch

  • Challenging mandate

    • Conserve the scenery and the natural and historic objects and the wildlife therein and provide for the enjoyment of the same, in perpetuity

  • Park often ahead of its time

    • YNP first to stop non-native introductions

    • Both fish and other animals

  • Formal Stocking Policies 1936

  1. Non-natives not stocked with natives

  2. Propagation of natives for stocking not encouraged

  3. No expansion of the non-native range

  4. No artificial stream or lake improvements

  5. No stocking food

  6. Some waters are left barren

  • Abolition of bait fishing

  • Creel limit decreased from 1930s - 1960s

    • Challenged the idea of maximum sustainable yield 

    • Against park philosophy anyway

    • Fisherman philosophy changed too

      • Too many people, too few fish

  • “Man and Nature in the National Parks” 1967

  • Trout Unlimited 1959

  • Federation of Fly Fishers 1964

  • Preferred “Limit your kill not kill your limit”

  • Stocking totally ended in 1959

  • NPS - preserve native fish population 

  • USFWS - mass produce trout

  • The 1960s Represented the dawn of the environmental era

    • Natural regulation

      • Bears, elk, fire, and fish

      • Not perfect but better

  • Surveys

    • Exhaustive, spot surveys, and fisher report cards

  • Future Objectives

    • Preservation and restoration of fish and habitat

    • Provide for recreational fishing

  • Signs of recovery!

    • Bears eating trout 19%-62% (1995)



Chapter 10

Fishing in Yellowstone

“How exactly do I catch something?”


Expectation and Reality

  • The size of trout dependent on 

    • Species

    • Environment

    • Management

  • Less than 1 fish per hour

    • Pebble Creek highest (2.5 per hour)

    • Madison River lowest (.4 per hour)

  • Always read regulations


The Season

  • Later than most

    • Late June through early July

  • Firehole and Gibbon River are the first fishable

  • Some rivers closed until after the spawn

  • September and October best months

    • No crowds

    • Fall spawn


A matter of skill

  • Cutthroats are most easily caught 

  • Before catch and release 30% of caught fish 

    • After 85%

  • Brook trout second easiest

  • Browns on Madison are experts only


Trophy Fish

  • 12-14 inch Brook Trout

  • 15-18 inch Montana Grayling

  • 19 inch Rainbow

  • 36 inch Lake Trout (40+ lbs)

  • 14-18 inch Cutthroat

  • 20-inch Brown Trout

  • Lots of small fish only a few giants


The Ecologic Angler

  • Fish aren't evenly distributed 

    • Feed facing upstream

    • Stillwaters, eddies, and shelters

  • All manner of flotsam

    • Nymphs and detritus

  • Just as complex as the terrestrial world


Finding Fish

  • Polarized glasses!

  • Reading the water

  • Avoid sudden movements, reflections, shadows

  • Fish needs

    • Food

    • Shelters

      • Weeds, banks, boulders, trees

  • Think like a trout

  • Riseforms


How can fishing help?

  • Release all fish

  • Kill all lake trout

  • Use less damaging lures

    • Flies less damage than treble hooks

    • Barbless hooks

  • Don't play your fish

    • Land it quickly

  • If your fish is bleeding it's going to die

  • Revive your fish before releasing 

  • 94%+ survival rate

  • Handle as little as possible


Conclusion

  • The goal is to allow the uninhibited natural world to produce whatever it happens to produce



Chapter 11

The Pleasure of Fish Watching


Practical Fish Watching

  • Easier than you think

  • Polarized lenses

  • Watch a good fisherman 

  • What are they doing?

  • Rise rings like rainfall during salmon fly hatch


Where to Watch Fish

  • Fishing Bridge

    • After ice out

    • Millions of eggs within sight of the bridge

  • Lehardy Rapids

    • Migratory fish jumping

  • Buffalo Ford spawning area

  • Look beyond the surface and enjoy



Chapter 12 

The Future


Invasion of the Aliens

  • Aquatic systems are the most susceptible to invasion

  • 1 in 3 freshwater fish imperiled

  • 170 nonnative plants in the park

    • Horse feed and car tires are the largest sources

  • ⅓ of fish are non-native

  • Tirage system of eradication

  • Whirling Disease is also a threat

    • Microscopic parasite that causes nerve damage

    • Fish chase their tail

    • Not yet in YNP

  • New Zealand Mud Snail

    • Pass through unharmed!

  • Anti-ecosystem culture

    • Often called communists?

  • Water scarcity


Yellowstone's Changes Role in Society

  • Source of hoe and rallying point

  • Strong philosophical questions

    • Why is fishing allowed if not hunting is allowed?

  • Surviving the crush of modern crowds


Good News

  • We are trending the right way

  • Changing public attitudes drive park goals

  • Experiencing YNP creates love!



Chapter 13

Fish List

Native Fish

  1. Yellowstone cutthroat trout

  2. Snake River Fine-Spotted Cutthroat Trout

  3. West Slope Cutthroat Trout

  4. Montana Grayling

  5. Mountain Whitefish

  6. Mountain Sucker

  7. Long-nose Sucker

  8. Utah Sucker

  9. Mottled Sculpin

  10. Redside Shiner

  11. Utah Chub

  12. Long-nose Dace

  13. Speckled Dace

  14. Redside shiner x Speckled Dace


Non-Native Fish

  1. Brown Trout

  2. Rainbow Trout

  3. Rainbow x Cutthroat Trout

  4. Eastern Brook Trout

  5. Lake Trout

  6. Lake Chub